Have eaten here many times and they never disappoint. My favorites are their chopped salad, Wagyu burger, and the 1# bone in pork chop that would easily feed 2. Their food quality is top-notch. Very friendly servers (especially Emily). The restaurant is especially accommodating for groups with special areas, splitting desserts, & separate checks. Watch for their 1# special priced King crab legs in Jan.

Delayed posting from a few weeks ago... Went here for a group dinner for work. We arrived with a slightly larger group than expected and a bit earlier than our reservation. The manager quickly got us the space we needed for our party and had us seated promptly. Our waitress was friendly and efficient, quickly getting our orders for drink and appetizers put in. Pennyville Station pays homage to the town's former name from the early 1900s. The outside patio is adjacent to the train tracks, which adds to the restaurant's moniker. We sat on the outside patio and the weather was perfect for it in early September. With such a large group, there were plenty of appetizers to share across the table. The mussels appetizer was delicious and tender. I could've drank the flavorful white wine and garlic sauce. Perfect pairing with the mussels. I also enjoyed the crispy Brussels sprouts with bacon. I ordered the salmon entree. It was served over a cauliflower rice, pilaf style. The salmon was moist and perfectly seasoned. The corn in the cauliflower rice added a touch of sweetness. If I'm ever in town again, I would definitely eat here again.

Let's just say their food quality is what raised the score. If it was based just on service, unfortunately, I would have lowered the score. Parking in this area can be a pain. Be patient as pedestrians are walking, and you may have to park a block or two away. They have daily drink specials and offer seasonal cocktails as well. My friend and I started with the oysters Rockerfeller. They were seasoned well and really delicious. I ordered a burger that was pretty tasty. I enjoyed the spicy mayo on it. My friend had the scallops and he enjoyed them. Service was incredibly slow. It took our server 25 minutes (yes, I timed) for our server to just take our drink order. She had her hands full so was unable to take our food order. It took her another bit of time to take food order. She was friendly. I would recommend and return to try other entree items.

First time trying out the restaurant Food was great Service was great rating the 3 P's On Brunch Price 9 Portion 9 Presentation 9 9/10

Pennyville Station is awesome. I have been here multiple times. The food is always really good. Have been here for both dinner and brunch which I highly recommend the brunch. The food, service, and the atmosphere is all very good. You won't be disappointed. Solid place to get some food.

Cute area. Thursday afternoon with a group of 6, seated immediately. Menu is diverse and delicious but pricey. Had the Ahi Tuna fancy nachos. American Wagyu burger decent Appreciate the water pitchers and lovely glassware

Aww shucks we liked Pennyville brunch! We ordered the oysters which was very delicious, the salmon burger, and the veggie omelet! It was a fun brunch, fun ambiance and very crowded barely could get a table!

My friends and I met up for brunch here and had a great time. We had a semi big group(10 in total) and they easily accommodated us. We have a reservation and called to push it up and it was no problem. I LOVE the ahi tuna nachos. I wish I would have just ordered it as my main dish! I ordered the lump crab eggs Benedict and a mimosa. The eggs b was very good. Lots of crab and very flavorful. My toddler accompanied me and I ordered her fries and a side of bacon and two scrambled eggs. The fries basket was very big and tasty. We shared with the two other kids at the table and still had plenty. The service was great. Our server was very nice and so patient with us. I know with big group and with kids it's hard. She was awesome.